On the so-called duty to achieve a specific result and duty of best efforts, and on fault as the liability criterion for defective performance
PDF (Limba Română)
JATS XML (Limba Română)
HTML (Limba Română)

Keywords

claim for contractual performance
claim for termination of contract
compliant execution
contractual liability
defective performance
duty of best efforts
duty to achieve a specific result
fault (presumed)
good faith
imputability
non-performance (without justification)
qualification of contractual obligations
risk of failure to achieve the intended result
risk of permanent impossibility of performance
standard of care acțiune în executarea contractului
acțiune în rezoluțiune
bună-credință
calificarea obligației
culpă (prezumată)
imputabilitate
executare conformă
executare deficitară
neexecutare (fără justificare)
obligație de mijloace
obligație de rezultat
răspundere contractuală
risc al imposibilității definitive de executare
risc al neatingerii finalității scontate
standard de diligență

Abstract

As the title is intended to suggest, this article seeks to reopen the discussion on the significance traditionally attributed to the distinction between contractual duty to achieve a specific result and the mere duty of best efforts. Beyond the legal designation, the focus will be on whether the performance of an obligation itself carries the same legal significance depending on whether the undertaking was assumed as a duty to achieve a specific result or as a duty of best efforts. In other words, the article examines whether any differences can be identified in the degree of scrutiny applied when assessing the conformity of the performance rendered to the creditor and, correspondingly, in the standard of care required of the debtor.

Furthermore, drawing a distinction between the contractual obligation itself and the obligation to compensate for the loss caused by non-performance or defective performance, the article considers the relevance of this classification of contractual obligations from the perspective of the rules governing contractual liability for loss caused by non or defective performance. Consequently, the discussion also addresses the meaning and significance of the debtor's fault.

https://doi.org/10.24193/SUBBiur.71(2026).2.319-365
PDF (Limba Română)
JATS XML (Limba Română)
HTML (Limba Română)

References

DOWNE A., *La gestion des risques contractuels par le contrat. Étude du droit français à la lumière du droit anglais*, Presses de l’Université Toulouse 1 Capitole, Toulouse, 2020.

GHESTIN J., Ch. JAMIN, M. BILLIAU, *Traité de droit civil. Les effets du contrat,* ed. a 3-a, LGDJ, Paris, 2001

ILIE G.-A., *Riscurile în contracte. De la vechiul la noul Cod civil*, Ed. Universul Juridic, București, 2021.

POP L., POPA I.-F., VIDU S. I., *Tratat elementar de drept civil. Obligațiile*, Ed. Universul Juridic, București, 2012.

VASILESCU P., Drept civil. Obligații, ed. a III-a, Ed. Hamangiu, București, 2024.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2026 Mihai David

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.